Skip to main content
Welcome to Deloitte
If we have selected the wrong experience for you, please change it above.

Own the fan relationship, not just the data

Platforms and ecosystems are reshaping sports, but the strongest organizations will protect the fan relationship by deciding what to own, what to rent, and where direct control can create a durable advantage.

Key takeaways

  • Sports organizations do not own their fans, but they can own the record of the relationship. Lasting advantage comes from keeping fan identity, history, and engagement under their control rather than locked within third-party platforms.
  • A single view of the fan is no longer enough. Real differentiation comes from generating unique insights, connecting data across partners and properties, and acting on what is learned faster than competitors.
  • Ownership creates value only when the organization can act on it. That depends on capabilities that outlast a launch, preserve what the organization learns, and allow people to act on moments that matter to fans.  

Chat with our leaders

For sports organizations, fan attention is no longer strictly concentrated on the game itself. Fans now discover, follow, and engage with sports across a growing network of broadcasters, streaming services, social platforms, athletes, creators, ticketing providers, and retailers.

Each touchpoint creates an opportunity to strengthen the fan relationship. But if a touchpoint belongs to an external vendor, the fan’s identity, behavioural history, or engagement data may remain in someone else’s hands.

While sports organizations do not own their fans, they can own the record of the relationship. The challenge is deciding where that relationship must remain direct, which capabilities to own, and where vendors can provide reach and scale without weakening long-term control. The question is no longer, “Which platforms should we use to reach fans?” It’s, “Which parts of the fan relationship can we afford to let someone else hold?”

Here are five choices that can help organizations decide what to own, what to rent, and where direct control matters most.

1. Choose which value the fan relationship must deliver first

Sponsorship leverage, direct revenue, and retention through a losing season are three different prizes, and each demands a different allocation of limited resources. The challenge is rarely a lack of strategy. It is working through the trade-offs: what ticketing, marketing, and media must give up to put the long-term value of the fan relationship first.

When Mercedes-Benz Stadium opened in 2017, the Atlanta Falcons introduced “fan-first” pricing, which cut concession prices roughly in half compared with their last season at the Georgia Dome. The organization gave up margin, but fan spending on food and beverage still rose 16% in the first season, and merchandise spending climbed 90%. Fans also rated the game-day experience among the NFL’s best.1

Prioritizing the fan relationship creates value that compounds over time. Organizations that own fan identity and behavioural history can continuously improve experiences and build something worth more in year three than in year one.

Key questions:

  • Ten years from now, what should this organization know about its fans that no one else does?
  • What is the organization willing to give up to put the fan relationship first?

2. Understand where the relationship needs to be direct

A relationship is direct when the organization controls the interaction, knows who the fan is, and retains a record it can act on with permission. Many interactions that appear direct meet only one of those conditions because the sign-in, terms, or behavioural record belong to another party.

Few organizations can, or should, hold every point in the fan journey. The challenge is identifying which moments are valuable enough to justify direct ownership. At the same time, the cost of building and operating owned channels has fallen. As fan attention becomes more distributed, the range of interactions organizations can afford to own continues to expand.

Key questions:

  • Where does the organization meet its fans most often, and who holds the direct interaction with the fan at that point?
  • Which of the fan interactions the organization prioritizes today sit on someone else’s platform?

3. Focus on what creates advantage, not access

A resolved view of the fan is becoming table stakes rather than an advantage. The advantage lies in what an organization can do with that view that its peers cannot: what it can acquire, combine, and learn faster than the alternative.

Organizations create that advantage in three primary ways.

  • Acquire what others cannot. Organizations can design activations, memberships, and experiences for which fans willingly exchange their identity and preferences, rather than purchasing audience segments that any competitor can license.
  • Combine what is held separately. Organizations can work with sponsors and rights partners to measure genuine customer overlap where consent and privacy law allow, creating insights that no single participant could generate alone.
  • Learn faster than others. Organizations can share models, signal definitions, and proven approaches with peers in other markets that rarely compete for the same fans.

The University of South Carolina shows what combining can uncover. After connecting its own ticketing, alumni, and donor data into a single record, it linked that record to merchandise data from Fanatics, its retail partner. The match surfaced fans who were buying team gear but had no direct relationship with the athletic department. Reaching them produced 1,400 new ticket buyers and more than $1 million in new ticket revenue.2 The demand already existed. It was sitting with a partner, waiting to be activated.

Organizations must be able to construct their fan profiles outside any single partner platform and control the rules shaping fan experiences. If they don’t control those rules, organizations might be able to execute day-to-day activities but will find it difficult to retain what they learned about their fans in the process.

Key questions:

  • If a direct competitor bought the same platform tomorrow, what would still be ours?
  • Which of our partners knows something about our fans that we don’t, and what would it take to see it?

4. Build the capabilities that make ownership matter

Sports organizations are typically well served by two capabilities: running systems reliably through game days and renewal cycles, and standing up something new in time for a season launch. The thinner capability is what comes next: turning a successful launch into something supported, extensible, and clearly owned after attention moves elsewhere. Sport widens that gap because a launch can run for a full season before anyone examines it closely again.

Closing the gap is not just a technology exercise. It requires people who can architect a business around fandom rather than the events that produce it, move quickly enough to capitalize on moments of attention, and create experiences fans cannot get elsewhere. For many organizations, it also requires reversing years of underinvestment in technology, data, and AI, whether through building, buying, or partnering.

Key questions:

  • What does this organization need to be excellent at that it has never hired for?
  • If a great activation idea arrived on a Monday, what would stop it from being live by Friday?

5. Challenge the assumptions that no longer fit

Fan centricity depends on more than technology. It requires organizations to challenge assumptions about how decisions are made, how quickly people can act, and how readily today’s model can be replaced.

Three cultural shifts make that possible:

  1. Be willing to make bold bets. Organizations seeking to shape their category need leaders who can make consequential decisions before the evidence is complete.
  2. Build a culture of action. Knowing the fan creates the ability to recognize moments that matter: a first match, a long-time membership, or a family that has travelled further than anyone else. What turns those moments into a relationship is usually a person doing something unscripted and specific.
  3. Accept that today’s answer will be replaced. The tools available today will soon be available to everyone. Advantage comes from adapting faster than competitors.

Key questions:

  • What is the boldest thing this organization has done for its fans in the last three years, and who authorized it?
  • When someone close to the fan sees a moment worth acting on, what are they allowed to do about it?

How Deloitte can help

Organizations do not need to own every capability. They do need to decide which elements of the fan relationship create enduring value, which can be rented, and which must remain under their control.

Deloitte helps sports organizations make those decisions with evidence rather than assumptions, starting with a clear view of where the fan relationship sits today and where value is leaking. By connecting insights, technology, and the people closest to the fans, organizations can act on opportunities more quickly and build relationships that become more valuable over time. This enables durable growth that stems from understanding fans deeply enough to create value in the seasons that go well and preserve the relationship in the ones that do not.

  1. Yahoo! Sports, “Cheap beer is good press: Why the Falcons' fan-friendly pricing is a win-win,” published January 31, 2019.
  2. Post and Courier, "Gamecocks use merchandise data-mining to find new ticket buyers," published April 22, 2023.  

Did you find this useful?

Thanks for your feedback