Skip to main content

Sustainable alpha

Shaping the future of private equity returns

Authors:

Claudio Scardovi: Senior Partner, SR&TA, Deloitte
Elisa Galassi: Director, SR&TA, Deloitte

 

Performance Magazine Issue 45 - Article 7

To the point

  • European private equity (PE) funds have consistently generated alpha, outpacing public markets and similar-risk investments over time.
  • Sustaining this outperformance requires evolving beyond traditional debt-financed, cost-cutting strategies.
  • A smart beta approach — targeting high-growth sectors aligned with long-term megatrends — will be key to future success.
  • Active portfolio management, supported by strategic M&A, will unlock operational efficiencies, foster innovation, and drive value creation.
  • ESG and sustainability are no longer optional; they are fundamental to long-term alpha generation and competitive advantage.

Private equity (PE) has long served as a vehicle for delivering superior returns, or "alpha," to investors, consistently outperforming public markets. A detailed quantitative analysis of European PE funds has confirmed that this industry has indeed succeeded in creating alpha over the long term, surpassing public markets and similar-risk investment opportunities. However, as the investment landscape continues to evolve, sustaining this level of performance requires a fresh, more sophisticated approach.

Relying on traditional strategies — such as raising debt and cutting costs — will no longer suffice in the face of rising competition, increasing regulatory pressures, and new market dynamics. Our research, coupled with insights from a survey of around 40 Italian mid-market private equity funds, highlights the importance of adopting a "smart beta" approach. By identifying sectors with robust growth potential driven by long-term megatrends like sustainability and digital transformation, PE firms can ensure continued outperformance. In parallel, active management of portfolio companies will play a crucial role in driving operational efficiency and fostering innovation.

In 2023, foreign investment surged in India, flowing in from a variety of jurisdictions. The year also saw a spate of regulatory developments that underscored India’s unwavering commitment to fostering economic growth, streamlining investment processes, enhancing transparency, and nurturing a favorable environment for foreign investors.

As the global economy continues to intertwine with India’s financial markets, it’s increasingly essential for foreign investors to understand the country’s regulatory framework and keep abreast of its changes.

This article summarizes the different routes available to foreign investors, taking a closer look at the regulations governing foreign portfolio investments (FPIs) and alternative investment funds (AIFs) in India. It also breaks down the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (SEBI) rules and compliance requirements for these avenues.

1. Moving beyond financial engineering: The changing role of private equity


Private equity has traditionally thrived on financial engineering —leveraging debt and reducing operational costs to enhance returns. However, the current economic environment presents challenges that demand a more nuanced, forward-looking strategy. While financial engineering remains a valuable tool, the future of PE success lies in its ability to adapt and evolve.

The investment climate is increasingly shaped by geopolitical instability, growing regulatory frameworks, and an expanding pool of dry powder — uninvested capital sitting at record levels. With over US$2.49 trillion in dry powder globally, PE firms face mounting pressure to deploy this capital effectively. The challenge is finding high-quality assets in an increasingly competitive landscape, where valuations are stretched, and the traditional playbook of debt-financed growth is no longer as viable.

As private equity adapts to these challenges, firms must prioritize long-term value creation. Success will come from targeting high-growth sectors that align with structural changes in the global economy, such as digital transformation and the shift towards sustainability. These sectors, including technology, healthcare, and renewable energy, offer robust growth potential and greater resilience to market fluctuations.

 

2. The smart beta approach: Targeting long-term growth sectors


In today’s complex market environment, a "smart beta" strategy is essential for sustained alpha generation. Smart beta involves a more refined investment approach — focusing on sectors and industries that are poised for long-term growth, driven by global megatrends such as digitalization, sustainability, and healthcare innovation.

By targeting industries undergoing significant transformation, PE firms can tap into new areas of growth while hedging against market volatility. For instance, the global transition toward renewable energy presents a prime opportunity for private equity. Investments in clean technologies, sustainable energy infrastructure, and energy storage solutions not only align with global environmental goals but also promise significant long-term returns.

Consider the rise of solid-state battery technology. As demand for renewable energy solutions intensifies, companies developing advanced energy storage systems are likely to see substantial growth. Similarly, sectors like healthcare are ripe for disruption, particularly in areas like biotechnology, telemedicine, and healthcare IT. The ongoing digitalization of healthcare systems, combined with aging populations, will continue to drive demand for innovative healthcare solutions.

Adopting a smart beta approach allows PE firms to position themselves to benefit from these long-term structural shifts, ensuring their portfolios are resilient and well-aligned with future growth opportunities.
 

3. Active management: Unlocking value through operational excellence


While identifying high-growth sectors is critical, generating alpha in private equity also depends on how effectively firms manage their portfolio companies post-acquisition. Simply acquiring assets and implementing short-term cost-cutting measures is no longer enough. In today’s rapidly evolving business environment, PE firms must engage deeply with their portfolio companies, providing strategic direction and operational expertise to unlock value over the long term.

Active management involves becoming a true partner to portfolio companies — helping them navigate the complexities of digital transformation, embrace innovation, and drive operational efficiency. For example, deploying artificial intelligence (AI) in supply chain optimization or using advanced analytics to enhance customer engagement can lead to significant productivity gains and cost savings.

Moreover, active management allows PE firms to guide their portfolio companies in adopting Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) best practices. ESG has become a critical factor in driving long-term value creation, not only from a regulatory perspective but also in terms of market perception. Companies that prioritize sustainability, diversity, and governance are better positioned to attract both consumers and investors, while also mitigating risks associated with non-compliance and reputational damage.

Fostering a culture of innovation and embedding sustainability into core business operations enables PE firms to create more resilient, competitive portfolio companies — ones that are capable of delivering sustainable growth and outperforming their peers.

4. M&A and consolidation: A proven strategy for scaling operations


Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) remain one of the most effective levers for driving growth and alpha in private equity. In fragmented markets, consolidation allows firms to build platforms that achieve greater scale, operational efficiency, and market dominance. Mid-market sectors, particularly in regions like Italy, offer a fertile ground for consolidation strategies.

In many cases, mid-market companies struggle to grow due to their limited size and resources. PE firms that pursue strategic acquisitions in these fragmented industries can unlock significant value by integrating smaller companies into larger, more efficient platforms. This approach not only drives cost savings through economies of scale but also enhances the strategic positioning of portfolio companies by increasing their market share and geographic reach.

For example, in the healthcare sector, consolidation enables companies to build end-to-end solutions that address critical needs — from biotechnology innovations to telemedicine platforms. Similarly, in technology, M&A activity can help firms capitalize on the growing demand for digital solutions by expanding their capabilities and client base.

The ability to scale operations through M&A is a key factor in driving long-term alpha, particularly in industries undergoing rapid transformation.


5. Sustainability as a driver of long-term alpha


The integration of ESG principles into private equity investment strategies is no longer a mere compliance exercise — it is a powerful driver of value creation. As sustainability becomes central to both consumer demand and regulatory frameworks, PE firms that prioritize ESG are better positioned to generate long-term alpha.

Sustainability-driven investments, such as those in renewable energy, clean technology, and sustainable agriculture, align with global efforts to combat climate change while offering significant growth potential. Moreover, investors and consumers are increasingly demanding that companies operate with a higher standard of social and environmental responsibility.

PE firms that embed sustainability into their portfolio companies' operations not only ensure regulatory compliance but also create businesses that are more resilient and attractive to a broad range of stakeholders. This includes integrating diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices, which help build more inclusive and innovative companies, fostering long-term growth and mitigating reputational risks.

In today’s market, ESG is not just a trend — it’s a necessity. Firms that fail to integrate these principles risk falling behind their more forward-thinking competitors.

Conclusion


Ultimately, to sustain alpha, PE firms must move beyond traditional approaches, adopting smarter, more targeted strategies to maintain their historical outperformance. To further success, focusing on sectors shaped by long-term megatrends such as sustainability, healthcare, and digital transformation will be crucial, through a smart beta approach. Additionally, active management with portfolio companies is essential for driving innovation, implementing ESG practices, and improving operational efficiency.

M&A provide offer an effective path to scale operations, increase efficiencies, and establish market leadership in fragmented industries. With sustainability now central to value creation, firms gain not only a competitive advantage but also enhance long-term resilience.

Therefore, the future of private equity lies in its ability to embrace these evolving strategies. By focusing on smart beta, active management, and sustainability, PE firms can unlock sustainable alpha and continue to outperform in an increasingly competitive and complex market.

Discover all the previous editions