The Deloitte CFO Survey: 2012 Q2 results
Confidence triple dips
The second quarter’s Deloitte CFO Survey, published on 9th July 2012, testifies to the impact of macroeconomic and financial uncertainty on sentiment among Chief Financial Officers and on their business strategies.
Once again, worries about recession and a breakup of the euro have knocked business confidence. CFO sentiment has zigzagged over the last year, plummeting on the gathering euro crisis in the second half of 2011, rising in March as the European Central Bank injected liquidity into the banks and, in June, registering its sharpest decline since the survey started in 2007. Therefore, along with the post-Lehman decline, CFO sentiment has seen three major dips in the space of five years.
CFOs entered 2012 with a view that a breakup of the euro posed the biggest threat to their businesses. CFOs now see a 36% probability of one or more countries leaving the single currency by the end of this year, up from 26% in March. Major UK-based corporates have stepped up preparations for the possibility of a breakup. 28% of CFOs say their own plans for coping with a breakup of the single currency are “all made” or “at an advanced stage” compared to 18% in March.
Business confidence has also been hit by the UK’s return to recession. On average, CFOs see roughly a one-in-two chance of the recession continuing to the end of this year or for the economy to hit a ‘triple-dip’ recession within the next two years.
The CFO Survey underscores the connection between the macroeconomic environment and corporate behaviour. In an indication of the challenges of long-term planning, 95% of CFOs rate the financial and economic uncertainties facing their business as being above normal. Uncertainty has had a corrosive effect on risk appetite and 80% of CFOs say this is not a good time to take risk onto their balance sheets.
Wiith the economy back in recession, corporates are reacting by cutting costs and bolstering cash flow, as in late 2008. Defensive balance sheet strategies are to the fore. Compared with a year ago, CFOs are more focussed on reducing leverage and disposing of assets, and less likely to be making acquisitions or undertaking capital expenditure. On balance, CFOs see hiring, capital spending and discretionary spending declining over the next year.
One of the special questions from this quarter’s survey sheds light on the factors influencing capital spending. Only 4% of CFOs cited the cost or availability of finance as having influenced recent changes in investment plans. 82% of them said investment decisions had been influenced by expected demand at home and abroad and uncertainty about the economic environment.
At least for our panel of large companies, demand seems to be a greater constraint on investment than shortages of capital. This fits with the Survey findings on credit conditions. CFOs currently see credit as being cheaper than at any time in the last five years. Credit availability has deteriorated, although overall credit conditions for large corporates do not seem to be especially stringent.
The first quarter’s CFO Survey highlighted a paradox: despite a strong rise in business confidence, CFOs were pursuing defensive balance sheet strategies. Events in the last three months seem to have vindicated such caution. Views on the degree of risk facing the corporate sector, like the equity markets, are changeable. But our latest survey shows that CFOs see plenty of risks ahead. Economic uncertainty is the big constraint on corporate expansion. The challenge for UK-based corporates is to find sources of growth in a volatile macro environment.
About the Deloitte CFO Survey panel
In the second quarter’s CFO survey, 137 CFOs participated, including CFOs of 39 FTSE 100 and 57 FTSE 250 companies. The rest were CFOs of other UK listed companies, large private companies and UK subsidiaries of major companies listed overseas. The combined market value of the 105 UK listed companies surveyed is £620 billion, or approximately 34% of the UK quoted equity market.