This site uses cookies to provide you with a more responsive and personalised service. By using this site you agree to our use of cookies. Please read our cookie notice for more information on the cookies we use and how to delete or block them.

Bookmark Email Print page

Cases

Tax Telegraph, September 2013

CasesResource Capital Fund IV LP & Anor v FCT & Anor [2013] FCA 801

The taxpayers were limited partnerships formed in the Cayman Islands. They owned shares in Talison, an Australian company, which they sold to a third party. The amounts payable to the taxpayers were denominated in Canadian currency and were payable out of a Canadian bank account maintained by Talison. There was no obligation on Talison to pay the taxpayers in Australian dollars.

In March 2013, the Commissioner issued notices of assessment to the taxpayers. The tax liability was denominated in Australian currency and it was understood by both parties that liability to tax under the Income Tax Assessment Acts can only be discharged by payment in Australian currency.

The Commissioner also issued notices under s 255 of the ITAA 1936 requiring Talison, as "a person having the receipt control or disposal of money belonging to" the taxpayers, to retain from that money, and to pay to the Commissioner, the amounts the taxpayers were assessed to pay. The relevant amounts were expressed in Australian currency.

The Federal Court held that the s 255 notices were ineffective as Talison did not have the receipt, control or disposal of any Australian currency belonging to the taxpayers from which to retain sufficient Australian currency to pay the tax payable. Nor did s 255 (or any other provision of the income tax legislation) authorise the conversion of the Canadian currency into Australian currency.

The Court also held that the word "money" in s 255(1) clearly refers to the currency of the tax obligation (ie Australian dollars) and not to foreign currency; nor, in the absence of authorisation or requirement to convert, does the word "money" refer to the proceeds of its sale.

Contact us

Adelaide
Paula Capaldo

Partner
Tel +61 8 8407 7136
Launceston
Steve Hernyk

Partner
Tel +61 3 6337 7060
   
Alice Springs
Neil McLeod
Partner
Tel +61 8 8950 7220
Melbourne
Geoff Cowen
Senior Partner
Tel +61 3 9671 7197
   
Brisbane
Lindsay Stanton
Partner
Tel +61 7 3308 7064
Western Sydney
Michael Clarke
Partner
Tel +61 2 9840 7277
   
Canberra
Melissa Cabban
Partner
Tel +61 2 6263 7106
Perth
George Kyriakacis
Partner
Tel +61 8 9365 7112
   
Darwin
Karen Green
Partner
Tel +61 8 8980 3028
Sydney
Spyros Kotsopoulos
Editor – Tax Telegraph
Tel +61 2 9322 3593
   
Hobart
Tim Maddock
Partner
Tel +61 3 6237 7065
 

Related links

Share

 
Follow us



 

Talk to us