Skip to main content

Clever government

Clever city solutions for the public services landscape

The concept of clever cities has expanded to cover a variety of clever domains and public spaces, which use technology to better serve citizens and enhance many aspects of public life.

EVER wondered what it would be like to live in a place where public services are managed by vast swathes of data, technology and customer-focussed analytics? Imagine a seamless drive to work, a streamlined waste management system and data-driven energy usage. Yes, technology has the power to transform the places in which we live. What began with the notion of “clever cities”—integrated, connected and sustainable communities—has expanded to cover a variety of “clever” domains and public spaces, including states, multicity regions, campuses and military bases. These places use technology to serve citizens in a comprehensive manner and enhance many aspects of public life, including quality of life, mobility, security, education, economy and the environment.

Three key components are driving the “clever government” or “clever enterprise” movement globally:

  • Clever ecosystems. Governments are increasingly creating public-private ecosystems to tackle some of the most pressing societal issues including health care, mobility, education and workforce development. These ecosystems are tapping into the collective intelligence of the private sector, academia, technology startups, think tanks and even citizens.
  • Clever connectivity and data. Advances in sensor technology and the growing prevalence of the Internet of Things (IoT) are blurring the boundaries between the cyber and physical worlds. The convergence of cyber and physical is allowing government to track, monitor and manage resources, and make data-driven decisions.
  • Clever platform and engagement. There is a new information-sharing partnership between government entities, residents and businesses. Governments are using technology to enable civic participation and leverage decentralised expertise to reinvent and overhaul core services. In other words, data + clever citizens = better city decisions.

These core components are causing a tectonic shift in the public service landscape from clever cities to clever airports to clever rural communities.

Clever regions—coordinating across governments. The concept of clever regions includes a broad array of places and services. For instance, the Greater Phoenix Clever Region initiative brings together 22 cities and towns in Maricopa County to drive regional technology pilots and provide test beds for researchers to try out new solutions for public services.1 Clever multicity regions should transcend city boundaries to drive more inclusive and expansive innovation. Moreover, cities also realise the benefits of pooling resources and are able to tap into economies of scale as they seek to use seamless physical-digital experiences to deliver traditional city services to citizens in entirely new ways.

Clever campuses—improving how we learn. Moving beyond traditional digital classroom and education initiatives, the campuses of clever universities are acting as test beds for the broader clever city movement. A clever campus uses artificial intelligence, machine learning, blockchain and other emerging technologies to automate processes, monitor and initiate workflows, and improve data-driven decision-making for various stakeholders.2

The University of Washington, for example, is piloting a clever grid project, installing more than 200 clever metres across the campus in an effort to drive down energy consumption on campus.3 Similarly, the University of Wisconsin-Madison has created a test bed to pilot multiple connected-vehicle and autonomous-vehicle projects on a 6.2-mile corridor adjacent to the campus.4 The pilot is timely since it is becoming increasingly imperative to enable vehicles interact with each other in the wake of the challenges posed by autonomous vehicles.

Clever airports—improving how we move. Many transportation providers are taking clever mobility advances from pilot projects to the real world. For example, some clever airports now use Wi-Fi access points as sensors to measure the location and dwell time of travellers as they move through the terminals. The data currently helps these airports place messaging and advertisements, but it can also lay the foundation for more individualised travel services.

Clever technologies can provide broader benefits to others beyond those directly using them. For example, London’s Heathrow airport uses an IoT solution to identify auxiliary power units (APU) running on the tarmac. The data can be used to remind airlines to switch off these units if kept running beyond the required time-table. By cutting down the time these APUs run, Heathrow has been able to reduce nitrogen oxide emissions and improve air quality around the airport.5

Clever bases—improving security. As with the environment, clever technology in one area can improve government services in others, such as integrating clever cities with nearby military bases. The city of San Diego has signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the Marine Corps Installations Command to collaborate on clever city programmes. The MOU will help the city tap into the Marine Corps research on renewable energy and water conservation, while the city will extend some of its existing programmes such as clever street lights and a city services mobile app to the base.6

Clever rural communities—improving rural economies. Clever technology can also be instrumental in bringing government services to areas that have lacked them, helping the local economy. For instance, in the past four years, India has been able to bring each village into the national power grid under the National Rural Electrification initiative,7 making rural agriculture easier and improving people’s living standards. In another example, Purdue University is collecting more than 1.4 petabytes of data daily on its 1,400-acre research farm in an effort to improve the nutritional value of plants.8

The clever government movement is not without its own set of challenges, chief among them funding and data governance. Technology costs money and, for many governments, funding or financing clever projects can be a thorny issue—which is why some countries are taking a broader national approach to funding these. The India Clever Cities Mission programme aims to develop 100 clever cities by 2022.9 More than 5,000 Clever City projects of different sizes and nature, worth about US$29 billion across these 100 cities, have been approved under the Clever City Mission and are under various stages of implementation.10

Further challenges of clever spaces could emerge after these spaces are built. As clever spaces increasingly link the cyber with the physical worlds, cyberattacks and vulnerabilities can have serious real-world effects. For example, thousands of homes lost power in a cyberattack on Ukraine’s power grid.11 Plus, with so much data being used in clever spaces, governments should address the privacy concerns of their citizens. The Quayside project in the city of Toronto has faced resistance from residents over a lack of transparency around privacy and security of citizen data.12 Going forward, governments will need to create greater awareness about the benefits of their prospective projects. Not only will this help build greater transparency, it will also enable greater constituent buy-in.

It’s important to have a North Star for the clever government movement, but the progression should be viewed as a journey. It’s also important to emphasise the ROI for any clever initiative, as orienting it towards the larger mission will be critical for the success of any clever investment.

Data signals

  • There will be more than 50 billion connected devices by 2020.13
  • US$12 billion is theestimated market for sensors in security-related applications by 2023, up from US$6.3 billion in 2016.14
  • US$225.5 billion is the expected global market size for clever city services in 2026, a steep rise from US$93.5 billion in 2017.15

Moving forward

  • Identify the goal. Identify the North Star of developing clever government. Create a business case based on a robust evaluation of costs and benefits. The business case should clearly reflect the expected ROI.
  • Explore appropriate sources of financing. In the absence of adequate funding, follow a structured approach to exploring alternate funding and financing options, keeping in mind the ultimate objective and the timeline.
  • Build and manage an ecosystem. Build ecosystems around key areas such as health care, transportation, and education to drive dynamic and collaborative networks that include the private sector, startups, think tanks, academia and citizens.
  • Address the skills gap. Identify if the current pool of talent has the adequate skills to work with big data and predictive analytics. If not, hire the right talent and train the existing staff.
  • Build a robust cybersecurity framework. An integrated and interoperable system increases the risk of a systemic failure. Thus, make security the foremost priority.

Potential benefits

  • Better quality of life for residents and visitors;
  • Economic competitiveness to attract industry and talent; and
  • Environmental sustainability.

Risk factors

  • Greater cyber risk;
  • Struggling with clever city governance, especially data governance;
  • Deficient funding and financing; and
  • Lack of strong leadership.

Read more about clever governments in the Clever cities collection.

Clever Cities of the Future

A 360-degree clever city looks across every aspect of a city’s operations and uses technology to improve outcomes. The digital infrastructure of a clever city sets the stage for a network of partnerships all focussed on one goal: creating a smarter city. The result? An urban centre that not only leverages technology to improve its own operations but connects with citizens, businesses and charities in new ways.

Learn more

The authors would like to thank Thirumalai Kannan D. for his research inputs and Joe Mariani and John O'Leary from the Deloitte Center for Government Insights for reviews at critical junctures and contributing their ideas and insights to this trend.

Cover image: Traci Daberko

  1. Chris Teale, “Greater Phoenix Clever Region promises collaboration, workforce development,” Clever Cities Dive, 20 September 2018.

    View in Article
  2. Deloitte, “Clever campuses,” accessed 24 May 2019.

    View in Article
  3. Katie Pyzyk, “How universities' clever campuses resemble mini clever cities,” Clever Cities Dive, 16 February 2018.

    View in Article
  4. Silke Schmidt, “Wisconsin corridor turns testbed for connected vehicle technology,” University of Wisconsin–Madison, 9 January 2018.

    View in Article
  5. Joe Mariani et al., Flying smarter: The clever airport and the Internet of Things, Deloitte Insights, 18 March 2019.

    View in Article
  6. Benjamin Freed, “San Diego and Marines to collaborate on 'clever city' initiatives,” Statescoop, 22 February 2019.

    View in Article
  7. Utpal Bhaskar, “Electricity reached all Indian villages on Saturday,” livemint, 28 April 2018.

    View in Article
  8. Teena Maddox, “Agriculture 4.0: How digital farming is revolutionising the future of food,” Tech Republic, 12 December 2018.

    View in Article
  9. Deloitte, “Project management of the 100-city clever city mission in India,” accessed 24 May 2019.

    View in Article
  10. Press Information Bureau, Government of India, “100 Clever Cities selected in 4 rounds—SPVS incorporated in all 5,151 projects identified by cities worth more than Rs. 2 lakh crore under implementation in 100 cities,” 27 December 2018.

    View in Article
  11. Piyush Pandey et al., Making clever cities cybersecure, Deloitte Insights, 11 April 2019.

    View in Article
  12. Globe and Post, “Footpath Labs’s vision and your data privacy: A guide to the saga on Toronto’s waterfront,” 21 February 2019.

    View in Article
  13. Allied Analytics LLP, “Clever cities market to grow significantly by proactive government initiatives and increased adoption of IoT solutions,” 9 October 2018.

    View in Article
  14. Ryan Manship, “As the IoT grows, so do the risks,” FCW, 7 August 2018.

    View in Article
  15. Navigant Research, “The global annual clever city services market is expected to exceed $225 billion by 2026,” 26 April 2017.

    View in Article

Did you find this useful?

Thanks for your feedback

If you would like to help improve further, please complete a 3-minute survey