Digital Commerce Remains a Largely Untapped Opportunity For Consumer Packaged Goods Companies
Only 43 percent of Surveyed CPG executives think their company has a clear, well-understood strategy.
New York, December 3, 2013 — Consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies are underestimating the e-commerce channel’s growth potential and consequently may be missing out on a substantial market opportunity, according to the first of a two part Deloitte study, “Digital Commerce in the Supermarket Aisle.”
The study analyzed responses from a survey of 2,040 online shoppers who are responsible for shopping and food preparation in the household, a survey of 43 executives and senior managers engaged in activities related to digital commerce at CPG companies, and in-depth interviews with selected executives.
One of the most significant findings revealed that, while both executives and consumers anticipate online sales of food, household and personal care products will grow in the next year and over the next three years, consumers’ intent to purchase these products online far outpaced executives’ expectations for both time periods. According to the report, executives expect 35 percent growth in the next year and 76 percent growth in three years. In contrast, consumers expect their online purchases to increase by 67 percent in the next year and 158 percent in three years.
“Increasingly, consumers desire the convenience of the online channel to purchase their groceries,” said Pat Conroy, vice chairman, Deloitte LLP and consumer products sector leader. “Although consumers are changing their behavior, CPG companies are not as prepared as the data suggests they should be to take full advantage of this growing opportunity. The importance of e-commerce to CPG companies has not, in most cases, translated into a fully-developed strategy for capitalizing on this channel.”
The study also found that while 92 percent of CPG executives agree that e-commerce is a strategic sales channel, there is a disconnect between the expressed opinions of these executives and the readiness of their companies to execute — only 43 percent of CPG executives think that their company has a clear, well-understood digital commerce strategy.
Digital commerce also has the potential to drive incremental sales for CPG companies, yet there is a disparity between executives and consumers that further suggests the channel may be more significant than executives believe. Executives believe that only 2 percent of the past year’s e-commerce revenue came from completely new sales, while consumers note that 10 percent of their online food and personal goods purchases over the past year have been completely new — that is, purchases they would not have made at all had the online purchasing option not been available. Accordingly, digital commerce provides CPG companies with the potential to take market share from competitors and, perhaps, increase consumption.
The “indifferent” consumer — potentially the biggest opportunity in digital commerce
A sizeable segment of consumers (41 percent) neither like nor dislike shopping at supermarkets for CPG products. These “indifferent” shoppers, combined with those who dislike shopping at supermarkets, are most likely to consider e-commerce for CPG products, as they have no particular attachment to the physical shopping experience. Given the right incentives, they could be enticed to shop online for their products.
Furthermore, while most executives correctly estimate that the majority of consumers dislike grocery shopping due to the time it consumes, fewer executives credit the additional factors that many consumers also dislike. These factors include inconvenience (47 percent), the crowds in stores (42 percent) and traveling to and from the retail store (39 percent).
Although consumers are unable to touch and view products online and do not like paying shipping charges, the report identified a number of drivers influencing digital commerce’s reach to consumers that have not been as widely available in the past. These factors include free at-home delivery (84 percent of consumers state this as very important or important), pricing similar to or less than traditional physical stores (80 percent) and free in-store pickup (67 percent). In the words of one consumer surveyed, “I like the convenience of looking at products online and having them delivered right to my door. There is a larger selection and very often, there are better prices.”
To gain competitive advantage, transformative opportunities exist for CPG companies across the entire path to purchase. Not only do executives see digital commerce improving brand awareness (90 percent) and driving product trial/initial purchase (86 percent), but it also has an important role in driving repeat purchases (93 percent) and reconnecting with lapsed consumers (88 percent). Also, the importance of digital commerce is expected to be amplified by the rapid pace of technological change. Most CPG executives plan to increase investment in in-store shopper engagement (74 percent), social referral (70 percent), mobile consumer engagement (68 percent), mobile market research (67 percent) and mobile e-commerce (67 percent).
“To successfully capitalize on the e-commerce channel, there are a number of critical steps CPG companies can take,” continued Conroy. “Executives first need to establish a clear and well-understood digital commerce strategy. They should collaborate with retailers and social media platforms, and build a single view of the consumer. In tandem with that approach, they need to foster and build a talent base within their organization that includes digital commerce skillsets.”
In the upcoming Part II of this study, Deloitte will address the transformative opportunities that exist for CPG companies along the entire path to purchase. Topics to be discussed will include driving product trial and repeat purchases, generation-specific strategies for digital commerce, and the essential differences across product categories (from food to personal care) that should inform those e-commerce strategies.
About the Survey
The Deloitte study included twenty minute web-based surveys of 43 CPG industry executives and senior managers, conducted from September 17, 2013 to September 25, 2013. Sixty percent of the survey respondents work in food companies, while the remaining respondents work in beverage, household goods or personal care companies. Sixty-five percent of the respondents spend at least 20 percent of their time on activities related to digital commerce (e.g., ecommerce, digital marketing, mobile, social media). A majority of respondents (51 percent) are from large companies, recording annual sales of more than $10 billion a year.
Further, the Deloitte study included twenty minute web-based surveys of 2,040 adults, aged between 21 and 70 years old, conducted between September 25, 2013 and October 1, 2013. Respondents were screened to target consumers who are the primary shopper and food preparer in their household and have purchased a product online in the past six months. The majority of the survey respondents (66 percent) were female, and the annual household income of 42 percent of consumers surveyed was less than $50,000, while 36 percent earned between $50,000 and $99,999, and 21 percent earned $100,000 or more.
About Deloitte’s Consumer Products Practice
Deloitte is a leading presence in the consumer products industry, providing audit, consulting, risk management, financial advisory and tax services to more than 80 percent of the Fortune 500 consumer product companies. Delivering insights on the latest consumer product issues, effective practices,technology and operating procedures, Deloitte serves companies across multiple categories including food and beverage, apparel and footwear, personal care and household products. For more information about Deloitte’s consumer products practice, visit: www.deloitte.com/us/consumerproducts
As used in this document, “Deloitte” means Deloitte LLP and its subsidiaries. Please see www.deloitte.com/us/about for a detailed description of the legal structure of Deloitte LLP and its subsidiaries. Certain services may not be available to attest clients under the rules and regulations of public accounting.